Discoveries for brass players, once a month. Join our free newsletter →

2 min. read

This article is free.

Editorial

Editorial

A debate for experts only?

Here are two different, indeed contradictory theses put forward by the great experts of our day. Peter Damm, Edward H. Tarr, Ludwig Güttler and Dr. Herbert Heyde will give their views on a controversial subject whose full importance we may not yet have realised. At issue is a stack of high-quality Baroque writing for corno da caccia, buried — practically unplayed — in libraries, awaiting the outcome of this debate to come back to life.

Until today horn players have not dared to touch them (too high) and trumpeters have balked at including them in their repertoire because of the instrument’s historical name ("corno da caccia"), which should, logically, consign it to the horn world. As for publishers, they remain cautious¹, and are following developments cautiously.

This is not just some scholarly disagreement. It involves choosing the form in which brass players will reveal these musical gems to the public. It involves knowing who, horn players or trumpeters, can bring these works to fruition by including them in their repertoire and making them public.

Güttler, Damm, Heyde and Tarr have each developed convincing and well-founded arguments. It is now up to musicians to hammer out for themselves a clearer idea of this problem and to join the debate — to take a decision, indeed, based on their convictions. A good exercise in perspective!

The historical truth is hard to discern and musicologists often get lost in a maze of supposition or analytical axe-grinding. Our four contributors do not fit the caricature of the musicologist cut off from musical reality. Furthermore, with the exception of Dr. Heyde who is a professional historian with a world-wide reputation, they are accomplished virtuosos on their instruments who have also studied the past thoroughly. Their commitment demonstrates their desire to reveal to us the historical path which leads to the present day and their attempt to isolate its authentic elements.

The frontiers of research face the future as much as they do the present or the past. This is reflective work, important for any musician who wants to know how to play his repertoire intelligently, avoiding anachronisms and the naïveté of mixed styles.

Concert audiences nowadays are informed and cultivated. Critics are often well-read professionals whose reviews are read by thousands. If we wish brass instruments to be included in programmes of a high standard, we must demonstrate our own knowledge and musical intelligence.

Notes

¹ Notable exception: the magnificent concerto by Neruda, published for trumpet (Artia Prague, Musica Rara) or horn (Billaudot), is one of the few original works for corno da caccia to have emerged from oblivion. There are many more of this standard!

Brass Bulletin 54, II / 1986 pages 3–4

All content is protected by copyright © Brass Bulletin 1986–2026

Share this article

Facebook LinkedIn
Loading…

Questions & Answers

How the Digital Edition works

What does the Digital Edition include?

The Digital Edition brings together the articles already digitized as searchable online texts—not simply as scans or PDF files—along with their original illustrations, notes, authorship, issue information, and available translations. Related-article suggestions currently include only this digitized material.

Are the digital articles identical to the originals?

We preserve the original text, language, illustrations, captions, footnotes, and editorial context as faithfully as possible. The presentation is adapted for comfortable online reading, and obvious transcription or scanning errors may be corrected. The substance and character of the published article remain unchanged.

Which languages are available?

Brass Bulletin was published in English, French, and German throughout its history. Italian and Spanish translations were added from issue No. 60 onward.

On the Italian and Spanish sites, articles from issues 1–59 are therefore shown in English by default.

How often are new articles added?

New articles are added almost daily, with approximately one complete issue digitized each week. The pace may vary depending on the preparation, image work, and editorial checking required.

Why aren’t all articles available digitally?

The complete Brass Bulletin collection contains 1,246 articles published between 1971 and 2003. The full index is already available online, allowing readers to discover every article in the collection, including those whose complete text has not yet been digitized.

Digitization began in February 2026. Each article is carefully prepared for online reading, checked, and connected to its issue, authors, subjects, and illustrations. At the current pace of digitization, the complete collection is expected to be available online by February 2028.

Why do some references mention articles that are not available yet?

References in the original articles are preserved even when the material they point to has not yet been digitized. This keeps the historical and editorial record intact. As more issues are added to the Digital Edition, an increasing number of these references will lead to articles that can be read online.

Can I suggest an article or report a transcription error?

Yes. If there is an article you would particularly like to see digitized, or if you notice a possible transcription error or missing detail, please contact us. Reader feedback helps us improve the Digital Edition and prioritize useful connections within the archive.

How can I support Brass Bulletin?

Your support helps fund the preparation, verification, and online publication of the complete collection.

Subscribe to the Digital Edition

Prefer to support us without subscribing?

Make a donation

How is the digitization progressing?

We’re gradually making the Brass Bulletin available online, article by article. You can read newly digitized articles as soon as they’re ready, even before an entire issue is complete.

Visit our Digitization Roadmap to browse recent additions and see estimated availability for upcoming issues. These estimates follow our recent pace and may change.

Search Brass Bulletin.