Explore institutional access Explore institutional access

3 min. read

How and why I became a musician

Part 1

By Edouard Gros

How and why I became a musician

Edouard Gros

Edouard Gros has had a remarkable career in Switzerland playing double bass and tuba. (His reputation as a tuba player was exceptional. He was in demand everywhere, especially for the famous “Bydlo” solo in “Pictures from an Exhibition”.) He worked at the Lausanne Radio Orchestra, the Suisse Romande (with Ansermet) and finally the Berne Symphony, where he stayed for 32 years. He was a regular member of the Lucerne Festival Orchestra. In 1975 he retired and went to live on the shores of Lake Geneva, where he enjoys his friends, his pear trees and his wonderful memories; he is going to share some of the memories with us (in successive issues) in the rich and joyful language of a musician — and a man — who has made a success of his life. (jpm)

Brass Bulletin image

My father

My father, a professional double bass player, sometimes playing (valve) trombone or baritone in local bands, trumpet sergeant of the 122nd Battalion, used to say to anyone who would listen that his son would never, never be a musician; he would wring his neck or throw him into the lake with an anchor round his neck before he would let that happen.

In his defence let us remember that at that time, at the very beginning of the century, a musician’s life was not all fun. The great majority of symphony orchestras offered miserable contracts, usually six months, sometimes nine months and very occasionally a year. The least unfavourable solution for anyone who wanted to earn his living as a musician was to play for silent films; cinemas employed anything from a trio for westerns to fifteen or sixteen players for some films. There were also restaurants, cafés and hotels some of whose orchestras drew crowds from miles around. Some very great artists such as Francescatti, Szigeti or even Casals, they say, who were not then as famous as they became later, did not hesitate to “do restaurants”. Apart from these gentlemen there were also some who were not so good and some who were just bad. Debussy, for example, having a drink in a casino somewhere in Brittany, wrote to a friend, “The first violin of orchestra X, accompanied by his band of crooks, is in the course of massacring my music while the sea withdraws indignantly!”

Apart from the insecurity, do not let us forget the scorn which middle-class people had for musicians, who they compared to acrobats and other gypsies. (People in the Swiss canton of Vaud still say of someone who is a good-for-nothing, has wasted his life and is too fond of a drink, “What an artist!” [Quel artiste!].)

So that is why my father the double bass player dreamed of anything but that for his son, whom he actually loved a great deal. “You’ll be a civil servant”, he would say. “Yes! A civil servant. With a good pension. The railways, or the Post Office. Government jobs, they’re good, the best you can get. None of this ‘six or nine months a year’ but for life, do you understand, for life.” He was obsessed by retirement. And at six or seven years of age I could not envisage myself in a station-master’s cap or sitting behind a counter selling stamps. There was going to be trouble ahead.

My father in the middle, my mother left and I sit on his right

My father in the middle, my mother left and I sit on his right

My father

My father

After all this, what do you make of a father who, although he did not want his son to be a musician, could think of nothing better than to send him to music theory lessons from the age of four or five? To salve his conscience he used to explain that a little music, amateur of course, never hurt anyone and that only an idiot could not tell an ascending scale from a descending scale. And then, of course, a bit of musical culture would always help you to appreciate symphony concerts and great soloists when you were older, wouldn’t it?

And that is why one day I was packed off to Mademoiselle Bouet de Montagnac. Yes, that was her name! A very old-fashioned French lady, as thin as a rake, short, and cannot have weighed more than six stone. She was also extremely ugly; to me as an unruly, mischievous lad, this was rendered attractive only by the fact that she had a moustache and beard like a navvy. She held a first prize from the Paris Conservatoire, adored her pupils and gave them an education which was of the greatest benefit later. Musical dictation in one part and in several parts, singing from music in several clefs, sight-reading, intonation — everything necessary for someone who wanted to enter this fine career. She also asked her pupils’ parents not to give them an instrument until after they had a solid basis of theory. She reckoned a minimum of four to five years for this whereas nowadays people start on their chosen instrument right away and are happy to polish up their theory later. I will not be so bold as to say which method is better.

My father at the double bass

My father at the double bass

My mother

At that time my mother never missed an opportunity to take me to the marvellous quintet concerts (piano, 2 violins, cello and double bass) at the Hôtel de la Paix in Lausanne where my father played. You have to smile when you realise that this kid of six or seven, fascinated by the music of Rimsky, Borodin or Fritz Kreisler, was even more fascinated by his father, tall, blond, with his carefully trimmed and impressive moustache, playing beneath a palm tree. How he was to be envied for being able to play beneath a palm tree.

...and I

I used to dream about this at night; I could still hear the admirable and adorable cellist Henri Plomb playing the many solos which the regulars never tired of asking him to play. That is how my decision came to be taken, quite firmly, even at that early age. That, and nothing else, was what I would do when I grew up although I did not know then that I would never once, in all my time as a musician, play beneath a palm tree, be it one which stood in a pot or one which grew on a Pacific island.

Finally, and to conclude this chapter, in the long-established tradition of sons who never (hardly ever) do what their fathers want, that is why I became a musician. If you like, I will tell you next time about how and under what circumstances.

(To be continued)

Edouard Gros

Edouard Gros

Brass Bulletin gallery image

Notes

¹ Canton de Suisse romande

² Chemins de Fers fédéraux, compagnie nationale

³ Poste, Téléphone, Télégraphe, compagnie nationale

Brass Bulletin 50, II / 1985 pages 69–73

All content is protected by copyright © Brass Bulletin 1985–2026

Share this article

Facebook LinkedIn
Loading…

Questions & Answers

How the Digital Edition works

What does the Digital Edition include?

The Digital Edition brings together the articles already digitized as searchable online texts—not simply as scans or PDF files—along with their original illustrations, notes, authorship, issue information, and available translations. Related-article suggestions currently include only this digitized material.

Are the digital articles identical to the originals?

We preserve the original text, language, illustrations, captions, footnotes, and editorial context as faithfully as possible. The presentation is adapted for comfortable online reading, and obvious transcription or scanning errors may be corrected. The substance and character of the published article remain unchanged.

Which languages are available?

Brass Bulletin was published in English, French, and German throughout its history. Italian and Spanish translations were added from issue No. 60 onward.

On the Italian and Spanish sites, articles from issues 1–59 are therefore shown in English by default.

How often are new articles added?

New articles are added almost daily, with approximately one complete issue digitized each week. The pace may vary depending on the preparation, image work, and editorial checking required.

Why aren’t all articles available digitally?

The complete Brass Bulletin collection contains 1,246 articles published between 1971 and 2003. The full index is already available online, allowing readers to discover every article in the collection, including those whose complete text has not yet been digitized.

Digitization began in February 2026. Each article is carefully prepared for online reading, checked, and connected to its issue, authors, subjects, and illustrations. At the current pace of digitization, the complete collection is expected to be available online by February 2028.

Why do some references mention articles that are not available yet?

References in the original articles are preserved even when the material they point to has not yet been digitized. This keeps the historical and editorial record intact. As more issues are added to the Digital Edition, an increasing number of these references will lead to articles that can be read online.

Can I suggest an article or report a transcription error?

Yes. If there is an article you would particularly like to see digitized, or if you notice a possible transcription error or missing detail, please contact us. Reader feedback helps us improve the Digital Edition and prioritize useful connections within the archive.

How can I support Brass Bulletin?

Your support helps fund the preparation, verification, and online publication of the complete collection.

Subscribe to the Digital Edition

Prefer to support us without subscribing?

Make a donation

Search Brass Bulletin.