Explore institutional access Explore institutional access

4 min. read

Dreams and wishes

Things I would like to see happen concerning the horn and horn playing

1.

A scholarly book (preferable to a dissertation or thesis) on the Mozart horn concerti, to include:

a) Facsimile reproductions (preferably 1:1) of extant manuscripts and/or earliest editions.

b) Complete history and background.

c) A clear and unedited printing of both the full score and the solo horn parts; commentary and discussion.

d) A thorough discussion of the performance practice of the period as pertaining to the horn concerti, including: trills, articulation, cadenzas, tempo, and hand horn technique. Possibly something on the order of Badura-Skoda's Interpreting Mozart at the Keyboard.

e) Discussion and comparison of: — Currently available editions — Recordings. Noting: the various aspects of performance practice, e.g. writing out the cadenzas. Also included should be a complete discography. Perhaps even interviews with the greatest living performers to record their ideas on the performance of the Mozart horn concerti.

f) If all of this were not enough for a book, the ambitious scholar could extend it (Haydn, Rosetti, et al.); perhaps: The Horn and Its Music in the Classic Era.

2.

All books and methods done in 2 or 3 languages. This is often done by European publishers, but virtually never by American publishers.

3.

Facsimile editions of the old method books (Duvernoy², Domnich², Dauprat, Gallay, Meifred, et al.).

4.

More original works and transcriptions available for horn solo and wind ensemble.

5.

To see the non-European horn manufacturers offer even half the number of models and options that most European manufacturers offer. And for all manufacturers to consider whatever of the following options that they don’t already offer: case covers, screw bells (at a reasonable price), adjustable thumb valve so that thumb up can be either F or Bb horn, water keys; also to consider making authentic copies of the horns of the Baroque and Classic eras.

6.

Having the International Horn Workshop in late July or in August when most European orchestras have vacation, so that the European member at least has the possibility of attending. And certainly any workshops held in Europe should be held during this time.7.

7.

Methods for horn which include cross references to books, articles, music, and other methods for further study, including those of other instruments or even non-musical texts.

8.

More contemporary works (especially by our best and most famous composers) for the young player. That is, in the 20th century idiom, but relatively easy (or shall we say accessible): for solo horn, horn duets, horn and piano, horn and small ensembles. If contemporary music is ever to really catch on, it will have to be through the young (the way they are getting soccer to catch on in America). We hope that the International Horn Society Composition Project will make important contributions in this direction.

9.

A gigantic undertaking: a new and comprehensive series of excerpts, to appear in the following main sections:

I. Standard symphonic repertoire (possible subdivisions: Baroque — Classic — Romantic — 20th century)

II. Opera

III. Chamber music.

And one single-volume collection of the most important excerpts from the entire series.

The work on such a project would best be done by a group of individuals of varying specialties working on smaller areas; they would crosscheck each other's work. They would not necessarily all be 1st horn players — or even all horn players.

The selection of excerpts would be on the basis of the repertoire encountered in today's orchestra. Special care would be taken to produce accurate, unedited music; at the same time, comments would be added underneath as to the editor’s experiences in the actual performance of the passage.

Each division would be alphabetically arranged. No "junk" or "filler" excerpts. It is possible that such a series could require 20 or more volumes for completion. But the need for an accurate, systematic, and comprehensive orchestral excerpt series seems apparent when one looks at the present books available. Most are good in one way or another, but fall far short of what is really needed.

A few examples: the Gumbert series is admirably extensive, but hopelessly out of date and full of errors; Gebhardt's excerpts seem to be largely photocopies of the Gumbert works; Moore's opera excerpt book is admirable in every way except that it is so short; Chamber's series is accurate and fairly extensive, but is arranged in no perceivable order and, as in almost all other excerpt books (Moore’s being the prominent exception), it includes no comments by the editor that we might benefit by his years of experience; Pottag's Vol. 1 is by reputation the best single volume collection, but it is riddled with errors and still contains too much "junk"; Thevet's two-volume collection, besides being completely unsystematically arranged, has no list of contents so the only way to find out what is in it or where is to go through the whole thing page by page. And so on. A comprehensive series of excerpts would be a lot of painstaking work even for a committee, but it would be a very valuable and useful reference for all horn players for a long time to come.

² Note by the Editor: these two methods are reprinted in facsimile by Minkoff Reprints, Geneva, Switzerland.

Brass Bulletin 25, I / 1979 pages 59–62

All content is protected by copyright © Brass Bulletin 1979–2026

Share this article

Facebook LinkedIn
Loading…

Questions & Answers

How the Digital Edition works

What does the Digital Edition include?

The Digital Edition brings together the articles already digitized as searchable online texts—not simply as scans or PDF files—along with their original illustrations, notes, authorship, issue information, and available translations. Related-article suggestions currently include only this digitized material.

Are the digital articles identical to the originals?

We preserve the original text, language, illustrations, captions, footnotes, and editorial context as faithfully as possible. The presentation is adapted for comfortable online reading, and obvious transcription or scanning errors may be corrected. The substance and character of the published article remain unchanged.

Which languages are available?

Brass Bulletin was published in English, French, and German throughout its history. Italian and Spanish translations were added from issue No. 60 onward.

On the Italian and Spanish sites, articles from issues 1–59 are therefore shown in English by default.

How often are new articles added?

New articles are added almost daily, with approximately one complete issue digitized each week. The pace may vary depending on the preparation, image work, and editorial checking required.

Why aren’t all articles available digitally?

The complete Brass Bulletin collection contains 1,246 articles published between 1971 and 2003. The full index is already available online, allowing readers to discover every article in the collection, including those whose complete text has not yet been digitized.

Digitization began in February 2026. Each article is carefully prepared for online reading, checked, and connected to its issue, authors, subjects, and illustrations. At the current pace of digitization, the complete collection is expected to be available online by February 2028.

Why do some references mention articles that are not available yet?

References in the original articles are preserved even when the material they point to has not yet been digitized. This keeps the historical and editorial record intact. As more issues are added to the Digital Edition, an increasing number of these references will lead to articles that can be read online.

Can I suggest an article or report a transcription error?

Yes. If there is an article you would particularly like to see digitized, or if you notice a possible transcription error or missing detail, please contact us. Reader feedback helps us improve the Digital Edition and prioritize useful connections within the archive.

How can I support Brass Bulletin?

Your support helps fund the preparation, verification, and online publication of the complete collection.

Subscribe to the Digital Edition

Prefer to support us without subscribing?

Make a donation

Search Brass Bulletin.